• Home
  • Gallery
    • Anniversary
    • Baby Shower
    • Birthday
    • Dessert and Seasonal
    • Graduation
    • Retirement
    • Wedding
  • Sugar Cookies
  • Menu
    • Bakery Menu
    • Cake and Cupcake Menu
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Cake Inquiry Form
  • More
    • Home
    • Gallery
      • Anniversary
      • Baby Shower
      • Birthday
      • Dessert and Seasonal
      • Graduation
      • Retirement
      • Wedding
    • Sugar Cookies
    • Menu
      • Bakery Menu
      • Cake and Cupcake Menu
    • Contact Us
      • Contact Us
      • Cake Inquiry Form
  • Home
  • Gallery
    • Anniversary
    • Baby Shower
    • Birthday
    • Dessert and Seasonal
    • Graduation
    • Retirement
    • Wedding
  • Sugar Cookies
  • Menu
    • Bakery Menu
    • Cake and Cupcake Menu
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Cake Inquiry Form

About Bethany's Bakery

Our Custom Cakes and Cupcakes

At Bethany's Bakery we give you the option to build your own custom cake! Choose a cake flavor from below, then choose and filling and a frosting. Our sheet cakes are 2 layers and can have 1 filling and our round cakes are 3 layers, so you can choose up to 2 fillings! If you do not want any filling we will fill between the layers with the frosting  chosen for the outside of the cake.

These are starting prices for cakes. Custom designs may increase the price

Cake Flavors, Fillings, and Frostings

Cake and Cupcake Flavors

Cake and Cupcake Flavors

Cake and Cupcake Flavors

Vanilla*

Chocolate*

Marble*

Half and half*

Red Velvet

Carrot Cake

Blueberry*

Strawberry*

Raspberry*

Apple*

Spice*

Confetti*

Almond*

Lemon*

Orange*

Maple*

*Can be made as Gluten free or Vegan

Cake Fillings

Cake and Cupcake Flavors

Cake and Cupcake Flavors

Any Frosting*

Raspberry*

Blueberry*

Strawberry*

Tri-berry*

Apple*

Cream Cheese Frosting

Chocolate Ganache

White Chocolate Ganache

Espresso Ganache

Caramel

Coconut Pecan


All of our fillings are gluten free

*Indicates Vegan Options

Cake Frostings

Cake and Cupcake Flavors

Cake Frostings

Vanilla*

Chocolate*

Peanut Butter*

Lemon*

Orange*

Lime*

Raspberry*

Strawberry*

Blueberry*

Coconut*

Caramel

Espresso*

Mocha*

Cream Cheese Frosting

Whipped Cream

Fondant*

All of our frostings are gluten free

*Indicates Vegan Options


Cake size and pricing

Cupcake Pricing

Additional decoration may increase cost

Cupcakes Each

3.75

Half Dozen

21

Dozen

42

Cupcake Cake

4.50 per cupcake

Vegan and Gluten Free Cupcakes

4.50 per cupcake

Round cake Pricing

These sizes and prices are for our (3 layer) round cakes

4" Cake

25

"Smash Cake" serves 2-3 people

6" Cake

47

Serves 6-8

8" Cake

69

Serves 10-12

9" Cake

91

Serves 12-16

10" Cake

117

Serves 20-26

12" Cake

198

Serves 36-40


Sheet Cake Pricing

These sizes and pricing are for our (2layer) sheet cakes

Quarter Sheet

85

Serves 20-25

Half Sheet

157

Serves 30-50

Full Sheet

350

Serves 75-100


Copyright © 2025 Bethany's Bakery - All Rights Reserved.


Powered by

Stay in the loop

Join our email list to stay in the loop with all things new at Bethany's Bakery

Email