• Home
  • Gallery
    • Anniversary
    • Baby Shower
    • Birthday
    • Dessert and Seasonal
    • Graduation
    • Retirement
    • Wedding
  • Sugar Cookies
  • Menu
    • Bakery Menu
    • Cake and Cupcake Menu
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Cake Inquiry Form
  • More
    • Home
    • Gallery
      • Anniversary
      • Baby Shower
      • Birthday
      • Dessert and Seasonal
      • Graduation
      • Retirement
      • Wedding
    • Sugar Cookies
    • Menu
      • Bakery Menu
      • Cake and Cupcake Menu
    • Contact Us
      • Contact Us
      • Cake Inquiry Form
  • Home
  • Gallery
    • Anniversary
    • Baby Shower
    • Birthday
    • Dessert and Seasonal
    • Graduation
    • Retirement
    • Wedding
  • Sugar Cookies
  • Menu
    • Bakery Menu
    • Cake and Cupcake Menu
  • Contact Us
    • Contact Us
    • Cake Inquiry Form

Custom Sugar COokies

Let us create sugar cookies for your next event!

Our sugar cookies are  $4.50 each or $50 per dozen. We require a weeks notice for all custom sugar cookies. 

*cookie cutters mat not exactly match inspiration photos but we do our best to get as close as possible

Custom Baby Shower Sugar Cookies

Baby shower decorated cookies
Woodland animal decorated sugar cookies
Woodland animal baby shower decorated sugar cookies
Sailor baby shower decorated cookies

Custom Wedding Sugar Cookies

Bridal shower decorated cookies
Bridal shower decorated cookies
Bridal shower decorated cookies
Baptism decorated sugar cookies
Wedding decorated sugar cookies
Diamond decorated sugar cookies
Diamond and Denim decorated sugar cookies

Custom Sports Sugar Cookies

Football decorated sugar cookies
Sports decorated sugar cookies
Volleyball decorated sugar cookies

Custom Seasonal Sugar Cookies

Penguin decorated sugar cookies
Ugly sweater Christmas decorated sugar cookies
Winter decorated sugar cookies
Flower decorated sugar cookies
Easter decorated sugar cookies

Other Custom Sugar Cookies

Space theme decorated sugar cookies
Old Bay decorated sugar cookies
Vile decorated sugar cookies
Nurse theme decorated sugar cookies
Gold and black 50th decorated sugar cookies
30th RIP youth decorated sugar cookies
30th decorated sugar cookies
Butterfly and hot air balloon decorated sugar cookies
Airplane and rocket decorated sugar cookies

Copyright © 2025 Bethany's Bakery - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

Stay in the loop

Join our email list to stay in the loop with all things new at Bethany's Bakery

Email